Showing posts with label Crime. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crime. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Cyclists - obey the law and die...!

Women are more at risk of dying in cycle accidents, it seems, because they are more likely to obey the law and stop at traffic lights than the typical male 'warrior of the road' [see article in The Times: Women cyclists 'risk death' by obeying traffic lights].

After endless close shaves or nerve grinding moments, every cyclist eventually comes to feel risk instinctively. (One of the obvious consequences of the recent expansion of cycling in London is the large number of new cyclists who haven't yet developed this instinct, and are apparently oblivious to hair-raising situations!). But I can believe the report about jumping lights being safer - one of the risky moments is pulling away from traffic lights when other traffic or pedestrians can make quite unpredictable moves and it is easy not to be seen. From now on, I resolve to carefully disobey traffic lights where this will reduce risk - it's a health and safety matter, or even a matter of survival. But what do we know of the risks...?

And survive we must because per kilometre, a cyclist is 14 times as likely to be killed as car user. The chart shows the risk relative to car driving [data from Social Trends 2007 table 12.18]. Good news is that the mortality rate has halved since 1981 for cyclists... but the data still give the lie to the familiar complaint from car users that cyclists are dangerous: "endangered" would be a better word. Motorcyclists over 40 times as likely to die per kilometre, and that has barely fallen. Is that just unlucky, inherently dangerous - or is motorcycle use preselected by people with high risk appetites?

The data of course reveal the extremely low risks for rail travel - but that wont stop billions being spent on rail safety awhile a few token quid will go on motorcycle safety.
... continues. Read full post.

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Atrocity exhibitionists...

There's much to inspire disgust in the Virginia Tech massacre - obviously the hideous acts and resulting toll of dead, injured, terrified, bereaved and traumatised but also the excess of righteous hindsight about what should have been done and the gun lobby arguing for guns on campus and that armed self defence would have prevented the tragedy [see New York Times]. But there is more to be disgusted about...

The other disgusting thing was the media handling of the killer's video and photo package. I admit I did look at some of the material, and I think I learnt something about this sad guy's alienation and bitterness. But I still think none of it should have been shown. Nothing.

But with a package of highly voyeuristic value, the TV networks couldn't resist this great audience magnet, and so came up with self-serving justifications for showing it: see NBC's explanation claiming it was a 'bad day at the office' deciding what to do (or rather how to pull it off)... and the BBC's feeble justification which ignores the main reasons for not showing this stuff... ... which are:

1. That it provides a huge posthumous reward to the killer which he should have been denied on principle. He should not have got his way even if too dead to realise because others, including those harmed do see his reward - and now YouTube etc will guarantee he is seen forever, which in words often heard affectionately at funerals "is what he would have wanted";

2. It signals to other potentially psychopathic losers and loners that fame, notoriety, immortality and specious power are there for the taking and that these might be worth more than your life and many others - just get the strutting Hollywood poses right, get some 'bad-ass' guns from your corner shop, pour out your teen angst and then start the killing - once you've put together and mailed the multi-media package of course - and while you are at it, why not try to beat Cho's record?

I can barely believe the cynicism: NBC should have handed the whole lot over to the police and left it that, BBC should have known better - free speech and freedom of information is not applicable here. My graphic attempts ridicule and contempt - the right approach to these images short of never displaying them... (with apologies to Banksy [gallery] and thanks to Microsoft's confused animal clip art).
... continues. Read full post.

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Cannabis - sorry about the apology

The Independent on Sunday reached a new peak of absurdity last weekend when it blazed over its front page: Cannabis - an apology and reversed its 1997 campaign for legalisation of the dope, apologising to its readers for leading them astray. The Indy frets that:

Record numbers of teenagers are requiring drug treatment as a result of smoking skunk, the highly potent cannabis strain that is 25 times stronger than resin sold a decade ago. More than 22,000 people were treated last year for cannabis addiction - and almost half of those affected were under 18.
It feels like a modern day Reefer Madness (view classic 1937 film) with 'skunk' playing the role of the evil marijuana. One struggles to know where to start with dismantling this rubbish! But lets try... ... continues. Read full post.

Sunday, December 17, 2006

Second oldest profession in the world - arms dealing

I fear it was a terrible move to axe the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) investigation into the Al Yamamah ("the dove") arms deal between UK and Saudi Arabia.

All parties have been stressing (implausibly) that the decision was not economic
- supposedly 50,000 arms-related jobs at stake. For example, see SFO's terse statement. The trouble is that OECD's Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions goes further in article 5:

Investigation and prosecution of the bribery of a foreign public official shall be subject to the applicable rules and principles of each Party. They shall not be influenced by considerations of national economic interest, the potential effect upon relations with another State or the identity of the natural or legal persons involved. (emphasis added)

Oh dear: the Prime Minister defended the decision as follows: [No 10 statement]

"Our relationship with Saudi Arabia is vitally important for our country in terms of counter-terrorism, in terms of the broader Middle East, in terms of helping in respect of Israel-Palestine, and that strategic interest comes first, particularly in circumstances where if this prosecution had gone forward all that would have happened is that we would have had months, potentially years, of ill feeling between us and a key partner and ally and probably to no purpose"

That contradiction with the convention, and others in the government statements, could form the basis for legal challenge to the decision [FT - Decision to halt case may be illegal].

Sorry it just doesn't add up...
Corruption allegations were extensive and serious [wikipedia summary of the allegations / Corporate watch]. The Telegraph reported that the Saudis were threatening to take the business to France [Halt inquiry or we cancel Eurofighters], and as if by coincidence a few days later the argument that national security was at risk was produced as the basis for closing the investigation. But why would the Saudis refuse to cooperate on security matters? They have a problem with Al Qaeda too.

Unprincipled
A novel argument was floated by the Attorney General
[statement]: It has been necessary to balance the need to maintain the rule of law against the wider public interest.

Might be worth reading that again...!! The Financial Times dismissed it as a 'specious assertion' and called the move A Damaging Cave-in. Wrong signals have been sent in virtually every direction: allegedly corrupt Saudis and arms executives have flexed muscle and won; BAE's shares are well up; Jonathan Aitkin is back on the telly; the day of reckoning for the UK arms industry has been postponed (but not cancelled) delaying diversification again; honest firms have been let down; the rule of law has come second to vague secretive assertions of national interest.

Bad news for international development
Much damage will flow from this, but hit hardest will be the modernisers in Britain's international development agency DFID and the intended beneficiaries of their work. Modernisers stress the role of good governance in securing development outcomes rather than just piling in aid. The most recent DFID white paper Eliminating world poverty: making governance work for the poor majored on this [see section 2].
As recently as June 2006, Hilary Benn was appointed 'Ministerial champion for addressing international corruption' as part of a package of anti-corruption measures. With hapless timing (suggesting they may not have been entirely in the loop) on 9 December and just 5 days before the plug was pulled on the investigation, DFID announced that: UK calls for more action to tackle corruption and Secretary of State for Development, Hilary Benn declared:

“Tackling corruption wherever we find it – whether here or abroad – is essential. We will not tolerate those who extort, corrupt and deceive. Together we can make progress and by strengthening the institutions of government, promoting better transparency and accountability and giving a voice to those who are hit hardest by corruption – the world’s poorest – we can make a difference.”


Ooops! Of course, it looks ridiculous now - the timing especially so. But the damage is profound: it's hard enough to exercise leverage on corrupt kleptocrats, but how can you do it unless you are acting in a principled way against corruption where you find it at home? And this does rather cut the ground from under the feet of those appointed to tackle corruption abroad.

What about the jobs?
The conventions and principles are clear. Turn a blind eye and you may win a battle or two, but you and everyone else will lose the war. I'm not convinced that this is a long term business anyway - the jobs are alreday heading offshore. Better think about finding something else to make or do.
... continues. Read full post.

Friday, July 28, 2006

Accessories to accessory crime

There are many annoying things about the mobile phone companies - roaming charges, poor coverage, high charges etc etc. But one of the most annoying things has been their tacit collusion in mobile phone crime.

The motive for collusion is clear - when a mobile is stolen, it is replaced with a new phone and a new user (the person taking the stolen phone) has access to the means to make calls. Muggings rose rapidly with the rise of the mobile, but fell only when there was effort to make it more difficult - both by policing initiatives in 2002 and by enabling the barring of stolen phones from 2002.

But it still seems to be going on - a walk down Kingsland High Street confirms phones can still be unblocked or sold for use overseas. And with more mobile devices there is (premature) speculation that mugging is on the rise again after falling since 2000. It just cannot be that difficult to disable stolen mobile phones, world-wide if necessary, but only if there was a a real will to do it by the makers... but there isn't and it's only under duress and public exposure that the mobile companies are belatedly doing anything about it (see BBC: Stolen mobiles will be blocked and the press release from Mobile Industry Crime Action Forum. One option would be to require the companies to replace stolen handsets at no charge - they'd soon find a way to stop them being used if blocked.
... continues. Read full post.

Friday, July 14, 2006

Natwest 3 - pour encourager les autres

Am I alone in feeling little sympathy for these guys?
Fact: there was a massive fraud at Enron
Fact: a lot of ordinary people were fleeced and hurt
Fact: many financial institutions facilitated the fraud
Fact: the FBI has a plausible case (see indictment & complaint)

There is something nauseating about the media campaign to protect them. If they stride the globe profiting from international capital markets and transactions, they can hardly go all Little-England when it comes to accountablity. That you might end up in a US maximum security prison, sends good signal to actual and potential white collar criminals.
... continues. Read full post.

Pleasing reversal of the week

The Home Office finally put a stop to its plans for police force mergers (The Times). The mixture of big-gesture, tidying-up and map-redrawing instincts that were driving this (with the flimsiest evidence base as a cover) were thwarted the moment value-for-money became a consideration. The ambition for reform has been steadily watered down from the bullish imposition 'strategic forces' (see Home Office statement 11 Nov 2005) to agreeing just to voluntary mergers, then abandoning even that. The whole reversal can be charted on what is surely a soon-to-be-removed Home Office page.

But why be against force mergers? Well it the current structure is certainly not how it would be designed from scratch, but the costs and opportunity costs of change are the reason to do something different. The costs have been estimated at over £1 billion, but that doesn't account for any loss of effectiveness. In my opinion, it is the distraction and opportunity costs that should sink the idea - mergers don't really address the key challenges:

  • fragmentation in IT and 'knowledge' systems as highlighted by Bichard in the case of dangerous individuals- but there are many other examples of poorly joined-up systems
  • the fact the the 'geography' of crime is not arranged on convenient administrative borders - for example crime in North Wales is more closely linked to Manchester and Merseyside than South Wales. Much crime has a London dimension, but no-one suggests merging everything with the Met
  • the need for much more co-operation, joint problem-orientated working, a means of distributing police capacity to where it is needed... none solved by mergers
  • the need for national organisation of some functions - for example terrorism, trafficking - overlaid over the localised structure.
  • the ever increasing need for specialisation, best organised at very large scale and usually involving London
There probably is a case for merging some forces, but the mistake was that a very prescriptive answer was put first and the then problem framed to find the desired answer. ... continues. Read full post.

Wednesday, June 28, 2006

What's the opposite of "human rights with common sense"

What is the opposite of 'common sense'? 'Stupid' could be right. Or 'arbitrary'. But one opposite might also be 'principled'... meaning that you stick to deeply-held principles, even if they give you discomfort in specific cases. Conservative leader David Cameron called for "human rights with common sense" as he promised to repeal the Human Rights Act and replace it with a Bill of Rights (BBC or original speech). He can probably have a Bill of Rights (which the Human Rights Act already is) or the appearance of common sense - but not both.

The whole problem with common sense is that it implies a very elastic view of what is right - ambiguous wording that would allow a view to be taken on the spot guided by what seems right (or expedient) at the time by someone in authority. That can never provide a useful compass in situations of great dilemma and difficulty.
In the last two days we have seen courts strike down convenient authoritarian fixes at the expense of human rights -UK High Court rules against control orders and US Supreme Court rules Guatanamo tribunals illegal - that is because principle is applied, not some expedient interpretation of common sense, and that's a vital check on executive power to erode liberty. ... continues. Read full post.

Friday, June 23, 2006

Home Office or giant squid?

After weeks of pain over prisoners let out, illegal aliens let in, and criminals let off, the perpetually distressed Home Office reacts to its plight like a giant squid, discharging vast quantities of a dark inky substance into its surroundings - that is vicious newspaper copy about the nation's most hated species... see left. The Home Office (press release) has expelled 60 paedophiles from probation hostels located near schools (presumably to somewhere where children cannot be reached?) and promised to consider 'Sarah's law', which would give public access to the address details of convicted and released sex offenders - responding to a campaign by the News of the World.

The possible negative consequences include: vigilante lynch mobs, offenders going into hiding or evading registration, or interruption of treatment and therapy. There are possible positive consequences in greater safety, parental awareness etc - and we should always challenge complacent officialdom insisting that the public cannot be told. I don't really know what the answer is, but I doubt that many others do either. The danger is that many think they do know - the News of the World claims its polling has shown 82% of support for Sarah's law, though the polling company, MORI, says the data is much more ambiguous depending on how the question is framed.

However, a department against the ropes might lash out with a headline-grabbing populist measure whatever the evidence says - and it wouldn't be the first time... Who would be to blame for that? Desperate politicians and their over-compliant officials, opportunistic cynical newspapers, or a panicked and suggestible public that elects the former and buys the latter?
... continues. Read full post.

Wednesday, June 14, 2006

The Times - it used to be a decent paper

Letter from me in The Times... The paper had an absurd front page saying "Support for Met Chief crumbles" because the police minister, Tony McNulty, refused to say the position of the Commissioner of the Met police, Sir Ian Blair, is safe in advance of publication of the inquiry into the mistaken identity and shooting of innocent Brazilian Jean Charles de Menezes. But the opposite would be much worse - guaranteeing his job would be a signal that ministers intend to ignore the report. Deciding that his position is already doomed is no better - because it would be based on leaks and spin. Whatever The Times is up to - it's annoying! ... continues. Read full post.

Saturday, May 20, 2006

Professor Sir Roy Meadow

It's hard to dislike anyone more than Professor Sir Roy Meadow - the 'expert' witness that consigned Angela Canning to gaol and her family to utter misery on the basis of completely incompetent statistical assertions designed to shore up his idiosyncratic theories about sudden infant death syndrome. And he has never even apologised.

So good news today to hear that the General Medical Council is to appeal against the High Court ruling denying its right to stike him off. And the GMC will be supported by the Attorney General. [BBC item]. The High Court's ruling was a disgrace, effectively protecting experts from the professional consequences of outrageous failure with extreme consequences for others.

The most famous claim with which Meadow mislead a jury was that there was a 73 million to one chance of two 'cot deaths' in an affluent family. There are two childish flaws in this statistical claim:

1. Widely reported: the events may not be independent - a common environmental or genetic factor may apply to the both the first and second deaths.

2. Less well appreciated: remember there are 1.5 million UK families that have 2 or more young children [data from ONS]. So if it was actually 73 million to one for a specific family, you'd be expect about a 1 in 50 chance that it would happen somewhere in that population. It's a bit like rounding up all previous lottery winners and accusing them of fraud because there's only a 1 in 14 million chance of winning and its very unlikely they would have won by chance. Add both these effects and it is hardly surprising these tragedies happen from time to time.

The best we can hope for is the Roy Meadow's reputation is utterly destroyed. personally, I think he should be behind bars - his negligence and incompetence caused far more agony than any assault or robbery could ever.
... continues. Read full post.